email app icon with a notification badge

10 Critical Do’s and Don’ts of Email Marketing

Email marketing is a powerful tool that can help you form deeper connections with your audience. A well-executed campaign can drive engagement, build lasting relationships, and boost conversions. But there are a lot of do’s and don’ts to crafting a successful email marketing campaign. Below, our experts explain the best practices to implement and the biggest mistakes to avoid.  

Ten Email Marketing Do’s and Don’ts

1: DO Build a Quality Mailing List

Focus your efforts on growing a genuine and engaged list of subscribers. You can encourage organic signups by offering valuable content and exclusive offers that are available only through your mailing list. Building a quality list means that your messages will reach an audience that is genuinely interested in your brand. 

2: DO Personalize Your Messages

Personalized emails create a more meaningful connection with your audience, making them more likely to engage. Use the customer’s first name in the subject or body of your message, and offer discounts on products they’ve viewed or favorited. Analyzing customer data can also help you tailor your messages more specifically to each individual. If you segment your audience into groups based on their preferences and behaviors, you can personalize your content even further.

3: DO Craft Compelling Subject Lines

Emails can quickly get buried in a crowded inbox, so it’s important that your subject line stands out. Keep your subject lines concise, relevant, and enticing. Try A/B testing with different options to discover which types of messages resonate best with your audience. Make sure to avoid spam triggers like using excessive punctuation and sensational language

4: DO Optimize for Mobile Users

With around 85% of people accessing emails on their smartphones, responsive design is crucial. Your emails should easily adapt to fit different screen sizes, and have easy-to-read fonts and obvious call-to-action buttons. Test your emails on various devices to guarantee a seamless experience for all subscribers. 

5: DO Create Clear and Concise Content

People don’t want to be overwhelmed with big chunks of text in an email. Keep your content clear and concise—use straightforward language, break up text with subheadings and bullet points, and incorporate visuals that enhance your message. Make it easy for recipients to understand your message and take action.

6: DON’T Overload Inboxes

Sending emails too frequently can overwhelm your recipients, causing many to unsubscribe. Strike a balance between providing valuable information and respecting your audience’s time and attention. Avoid sending more than three emails a month, and stick to a consistent frequency. 

7: DON’T Buy or Sell Email Lists

Resist the urge to simply purchase or sell email lists. While it may seem like a shortcut to growing your subscriber base, it typically results in sending the majority of your messages to uninterested contacts. Focus on organic methods to grow your email list, such as promoting your content on social media and offering incentives like access to exclusive offers. 

8: DON’T Neglect A/B Testing

A/B testing is essential to optimizing your email campaigns. Neglecting it means missing out on valuable insights that can increase engagement and drive sales. Experiment with different elements such as subject lines, content, visuals, and calls-to-action to refine your strategies according to the preferences of your audience. 

9: DON’T Use Misleading Subject Lines

Deceptive subject lines can damage your credibility and cause distrust among your audience. Always be transparent and accurate in your subject lines to set the right expectations. While “clickbait” subject lines may lead to higher open rates initially, they can harm your long term relationships with your subscribers and lead to more opt-outs. 

10: DON’T Ignore Regulations

Compliance with email marketing regulations is non-negotiable. Ignoring regulations like the CAN-SPAM Act can have severe consequences, including legal issues and permanent damage to your brand’s reputation. Always obtain explicit consent, provide clear opt-out options, and stay informed about relevant laws in your target regions. 

Take Your Email Marketing to the Next Level

By implementing these best practices, you can create compelling campaigns that resonate with your audience, drive engagement, and nurture your relationships with your subscribers. However, keeping up with the do’s and don’ts of email marketing can be time-consuming. At New Wine Digital, our experienced online marketing team can help your business reach more prospects with consistent and relevant newsletters. Contact us today to learn more about our email marketing services. 


Images used under creative commons license – commercial use (1/1/2024). Photo by Brett Jordan on Unsplash 

Scroll to Top